Predicted History in Daniel

Does the Bible predict world events? The book of Daniel has been controversial because it contains prophesies that are now about events which to us are history. I did some study of how Daniel chapter 11 relates to history. It is a bit like discovering a large, tangled knot with several strands of thread or wires protruding out of it. Then you decide to try and unravel it. Something in me likes the challenge of untangling a large, complicated knot. With the book of Daniel much of the controversy is about when it was written and who the writer of Daniel was. So, among scholars you have the “biblical minimalists” and the “biblical maximalists” who take different views of the prophesies in Daniel. There is a large degree of agreement among scholars that the content of the prophetic sections does actually agree with the history as we know it. But the biblical minimalists do not accept that God could reveal details about events in the world affecting many peoples and nations years before they ever happened. So the minimalists suggest various scenarios that are naturalistic explanations that do not require miraculous revelation of future events to Daniel. The minimalists believe the book of Daniel was not written by the man named Daniel in the book, but was written sometime in the period around 167 to 153 B.C. This would make it written long after all the events mentioned in the prophecies happened. The biblical maximalists on the other hand argue that it was written by Daniel during his lifetime, which was during the exile into Babylon, meaning it was written about 559 B.C. This would have been during the reign of Cyrus II of Persia.

What follows here is a summary of a long presentation I did at my church. The date of the writing of Daniel is critical because the biblical minimalists would say that the writer of Daniel was incorrect on a number of historical details. I think this conclusion is incorrect because it comes from incorrect assumptions. Both the Old Testament and the New Testament are historically accurate, though we do not always have all the answers. The book of Daniel is unusual because it is written in two languages, ancient Aramaic and Hebrew. Some of the early chapters are in Aramaic. What I focus on is Daniel chapter 11, which was written in Hebrew. If the later date of the writing of Daniel were correct, that would make it roughly 400 years after the events it describes. The Aramaic language was already falling out of usage by then and some have argued that if it were written in 160 or 150 B.C. it would be odd for them to write portions in that language. But a more important reason to take the earlier date for the writing is that the Jews would not have accepted anyone as a prophet at the later date. Josephus and other Jewish writings affirm there were no prophets during the period between 559 and 150 B.C. The Jews would not have accepted a new writing as canonical in the period of 160 to 150 B.C. I think Daniel is written in a manner that fits with the writer being a person with many years of experience, as Daniel would have had. It is authentic in its descriptions. The controversies about particular names and details are easily answered it seems to me from historical background known now. So I confess to being a biblical maximalist regarding Daniel and the Old Testament in general and I accept that the book of Daniel was written by the man described in the book.

One of the things skeptics have brought up is that the Bible refers to a man called “Darius the Mede” or “Darius son of Ahasuerus, of the seed of the Medes” in Daniel 9:1, 5:31, and 6:28. Skeptics have challenged this saying there was no one called Darius at this time. In Daniel 10:1 it makes clear that it was the third year of Cyrus king of Persia when he began writing the section including chapter 11. Kings of those times often had multiple names and multiple titles. There were “throne names” different from their actual given name. This creates some confusion. Another practice was that when the ruling king changed, the same “throne name” might have continued to have been used by the new king. Cyrus II also called Cyrus the Great conquered Media prior to conquering Babylon. Then married two wives, one Persian and the other Median. The person mentioned in Daniel 9:1 was not the person we know of from the wars of the Greeks and the Persians as Darius I, that was after 521 B.C. But the title Darius had apparently been in use by the Medes, as had the title Ahasuerus. So whoever would have been the new king of the Medes could have been called “Darius the Mede” because that title was already in use. The person referred to in Daniel 9:1 could have been one of the Medes that would have been in line to rule the Medes, or it could be just referring to Cyrus II. A few sources say there was a man called Cyaxares II who was a Mede who was the Darius in Daniel 9:1. But I suspect it’s most likely just Cyrus II using the Median title. This name controversy is not a serious issue really. It doesn’t affect many details in Daniel 11 that agree nicely with history. So I do not agree that “Darius the Mede” is historically inaccurate. Also, it is important to note that the prophet Isaiah 44:28 mentions Cyrus by name and in this verse God is calling Cyrus “my shepherd” long before he was born.

I will mention just a few of the ways in which Daniel 11 aligns with what we know from history. Daniel 11:2 begins the prophesies by spelling out information about 4 kings of Persia that were to follow Cyrus the Great. From the NIV 1984, “Now then, I tell you the truth: Three more kings will appear in Persia, and then a fourth, who will be far richer than all the others. When he has gained power by his wealth, he will stir up everyone against the kingdom of Greece.” We can name these kings from history. Also the details of what we know from history confirm and add color to the story, they do not show the Bible to be historically inaccurate. The first of the four Persian kings is Cambyses II – who reigned from 530 – 522 B.C. The second one has multiple names because he apparently impersonated a son of Cyrus. He is known as Bardiya or Smerdis but was also called Gaumata. There is some disagreement among scholars as to the exact details, but this man only ruled for about 7 months. The third Persian king was Darius I (521 – 486 B.C.). There is much familiar history around this king. Darius I greatly expanded the kingdom of Persia, especially westward. But when Darius tried to conquer Greece he was able to take a few cities but ultimately lost the war with Greece. The famous battle of Marathon marked the defeat of Darius’ army (in 490 B.C.). An important thing to note about Darius is that after expanding Persian territory he created some of the first paved roads and also set up something similar to what was called the “Pony Express” later in the United States, for sending messages. This greatly facilitated trade in Persia. Then we come to the fourth Persian king, who is described as far richer than the others. This was Xerxes I, also known by the title Ahasuerus. This was the king of Persia at the time of Esther, in the Old Testament book of Esther. Xerxes I (reigned from 485 – 465 B.C.) became very wealthy because of the trade that took place starting at the time of his father Darius and continuing into his reign. After becoming very wealthy and powerful, Xerxes wanted to get revenge on the Greeks for their defeat of his father, so he roused the Persians to go and attack Greece. The famous battle of Thermopylae where the 300 Spartans died was 480 B.C. Xerxes ultimately lost again against the Greeks. This passage in the Bible is extraordinary because of how it ties the Bible into the histories of both Western and Eastern nations.

Verses 3 and 4 of Daniel 11 mention a powerful leader who comes after the four Persian kings above. It says “Then a mighty king will appear, who will rule with great power and do as he pleases. After he has appeared, his empire will be broken up and parceled out toward the four winds of heaven. It will not go to his descendants, nor will it have the power he exercised, because his empire will be uprooted and given to others (NIV 1984).” Everyone seems to agree among scholars that this is referring to Alexander the Great, from Macedonia in Greece. The agreement of this with history is extraordinary. The following is how it happened from historical information. Alexander was a brilliant General. He attacked Persia after they had weakened and he defeated them. But after he conquered all the territory, he mysteriously dies in 323 B.C. The territory he conquered was split up among four main generals: Ptolemy, Antigonus, Cassander, and Seleucus. Alexander had two wives, one Greek (Stateira II) and one Persian (Roxana). He only had two children (sons). The son of Stateira had some mental handicap. He was briefly put in power but under the control of a man who was Regent. But this son was killed by Roxana. His other son was called Alexander IV. Though protected for a time, Roxana and Alexander IV were killed by Cassander. Thus, Alexander’s conquered territory was not ruled by one of his descendants, and his kingdom was broken up and weakened. Alexander’s former generals became rulers of different territories and started hundreds of years of rivalry and conflict between the Ptolemies in Egypt, the Seleucids, and the Greek states. Later on, the Romans were also a factor. The history of the Ptolemies and Seleucids is significant Biblically because Israel was right in the middle between these competing kingdoms. So, the ones in power over Israel and the Jews changed over time. Daniel 11 explains to Daniel a long complex history in summary terms that details the time between the Old and New Testaments and what was going to happen to Daniel’s people after his time.

There are many details in Daniel 11 that can be related to what is now well-known history. Some of it includes large battles in which considerable historical detail of the battles themselves are known. It has broad agreement with the Bible at many points, though the Bible does not detail everything we know now from the history. It follows for instance that the Kingdom of the South (the Ptolemies) were in power over Israel until a battle known as the battle of Panium in 200 B.C., where Antiochus III of the Seleucids (the King of the North in Daniel) defeated the South for good. Later, in Daniel 11:29 Scripture seems to describe the Romans as “ships of the western coastlands,” who intervened to convince Antiochus IV to stop his attack on Egypt. This was during a period where Rome was growing in power and influence, and Antiochus IV did not want to challenge Rome while fighting other battles on other fronts. But both the Ptolemies and the Seleucids spread Greek culture, knowledge, and the Greek language over much of the known world. The spreading of the Greek language was likely significant in preparing for the gospel to be spread across the world later after Jesus’ life and ministry in the first century A.D. The Greeks also preserved knowledge and advanced science and mathematics in important ways that benefit us to this day.

My study of this period of history has shown me that God is sovereign over the rise and fall of leaders and nations, whether they are good or evil. Both the Ptolemies and the Seleucids had corrupt leaders, yet God used them to oversee his people the Jews in one of the most difficult periods of their history. Also, the events of this period of history provide some background for understanding the New Testament. So, though the political winds blow one way and then another, God does know what He is doing. But, according to God’s timing and purpose, we have a part to play.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.